I appreciate the efforts everyone. And I think Marian summed up the sentiment perfectly
If I may be self indulgent,
here is my review at the time - just so you know what you are missing (actually, having read that, it probably IS a dark side game

)
Here is mine
Bioshock
Dead Space 2
Divine Divinity
ES Oblivion
ES Skyrim
Fallout 3
Half Life 2
Ico
Limbo
Outcast
Portal 2
Realms of the Haunting
Witcher