My take: I played this game last month. One of those games with a WIDE variability in the difficulty of the various puzzles, which can be annoying to some players. It was a nice, long game, but not the best in the series. I would rate both Curse of the Swamp and Two Kingdoms as better games in this series. Curse is an older game, a bit cutesy and cartoony, but long and fun to play. Two Kingdoms is a BIG game with a long story and tons of puzzles and other things to do. I definitely will replay it after a year or so. Don't plan to replay Guardian.