I'm playing Black Mirror 1 also. I'm trying to take the attic key from the wall next to the cellar door. Each time I click on the panel with keys, Samuel says: "this must be the cellar door key. I had better leave it here." I see TWO keys on the key panel, but I can't take the attic key. The attic is still locked so I'm stuck at this point. Any help would be appreciated.
NOTE: This comes after I had used the savegame for the "Torn Photo" puzzle
Never mind problem solved. I had to run around looking for Bates (the butler). Finally found him in the kitchen, and then I asked him about the attic key, telling me (Samuel) that the key was next to the cellar door. I now was able to take the attic key. Now I am finally in the attic. YAY!
All this because I had used that savegame, but now I'm thankful that I did, so I'm finally moving forward. WHEW!
Edited by sanford (02/04/18 03:57 AM)
Edit Reason: added text