Hi All,
Originally I was going to ask for just one game but discovered I had a problem placing these 5 above as a best of all time so I decided to go for 5. My picks in no particular order are The Beast Within, TLJ, Black Dahlia, Moment of Silence (think I might have to duck for cover here but I loved the story and the graphics) and Syberia. Honorable mention goes to 2 of the Tex games UAKM and Pandora Directive.

Warm Regards to All,
Barry

Hi Barry, have you checked out our list HERE?
And I loved Moment of Silence!

Ana

Hi Ana,
I know about the recommendations list but I wanted things narrowed down to 5 all time favorites. Most of the time with the recommend list there are 15-20 games listed in no particular order and the final was just a hit total of the most selected in the entries. I was more curious about indivdual favorites and the type of games the individual members liked the most limiting it to 5 (not so much of a recommendation list but as a way of getting to know who likes what type of games).

Warm Regards,
Barry

PS the reason for my comment with TMOS was it was one of those games with no middle ground, it was either loved or hated.

Barry, my 5 picks are GK2 (The Beast Within), TLJ, Syberia, Riven, and Obsidian.

Thanks for the link, Ana, I'll have to check it out!

My most favorite games are..
Blackstone Chronicles
Runaway
Broken Sword 3-4
Nancy Drew Ghost Dogs

My five favorites are Syberia, Tomb Raider Chronicles, Dark Fall, Myst Revelation and Myst.

5. Gabriel Knight 1
4. The Longest Journey
3. Monkey Island 1
2. Grim Fandango
1. Monkey Island 2

Here is my complete Top 50.

Riven
Blackstone Chronicles
Sanitarium
Syberia
Myst
Boy this was hard.If these are not in the top five
they are in the top ten for sure.....Ron

Syberia 1&2
Simon the Socererer 1&2
Runaway 1&2
Return to Mysterious Island
Secret Files of Tunguska

The problem is all the others that I love but if only 5 to take to my desert island I think it would be these. Have I cheated as that is 8 games!

5--I don't think I can do that

I'm with L4L - as in, me neither! But 3 of your 5 would be in my top ten for sure Barry (GK2, TMOS, TLJ).

My Top 5:

1. Black Mirror
2. Still Life
3. Secrets of Da Vinci
4. Syberia
5. Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Silver Earring

The 5 I seem to play over and over are: The Longest Journey. Syberia. Syberia 2. Stupid Invaders. Clue: The Fatal Illusion.

Riven
Obsidian
Rhem
Riddle of the Sphinx
Gabriel Knight 2 Beast Within

So many games...So little time!
Barry -- The only way I could possibly answer this question would be if I seperated the games by categories.

ADVENTURE

• Riven
• Syberia
• The Longest Journey
• Mysterious Island
• Riddle of the Sphinx

ACTION

• The Chronicles of Riddick
• Tomb Raider Anniversary
• Resident Evil 4
• The Prince of Persia Sands of Time
• Peter Jacksons King Kong

FIRST PERSON SHOOTERS

• Halo
• Far Cry
• Half Life 2
• Prey
• Doom 3

ROLL PLAYING GAMES

• Star Wars Knights of the Old Republic
• Elder Scrolls 4: Oblivion
• Elder Scrolls 4: Knights of the Nine
• Elder Scrolls 4: Shivering Isles
• Elder Scrolls 3: Morrowwind

I don't know who I'm kidding ROTFL Their all the best, and their all my favorites! And thats not counting Stealth and Horror