My replayed games, all the myst series these are, in my opinion the goldengames and I play them all at least once a year. Others Safecracker(latest) love those puzzles, messenger and traitors gate. I am seduced by new games but always go back to one of these when I am bored. If I can ever solve the problem I have with Culpa Inata I might play that one again. It might even become a favorite.

With out a doubt Mystt playing it on he DS now

Without a doubt, Pandora Directive!

Day of the Tentacle is tied with Discworld Noir over here.

I have replayed games I like. The one I find myself going back to most often is Journeyman 3: Legacy of Time. One of the most fun and best made games I have ever seen. Unfortunately Arthur does not get any less annoying as time goes on but he is necessary in some areas.

It takes me so long to finish games and I always have a backlog of unplayed games, the only one I replayed was Outcast-It was just so intriguing to me I couldn't leave it right away.

I would like to replay Anachronox, the Thief games, the Syberias, and Noone Lives Forever, maybe someday.

Lately I've been selling games I dont think I will ever replay-but even being careful about BAAGing too much I still have 21 games unplayed.

The longest journey, by far. I played this game like 7 times. It's just an amazing game, and it'll probably be the best adventure game ever (well at least to me).

I play all my games at least twice. Sometimes right after finishing so I can concentrate on the story rather than the puzzles but more often about a year later. I'm replaying Jack the Ripper again after about 9 months and enjoying it as much as I did the first time.

I am like bigmomma. Too many unplayed on the shelf to play many again. Outcast is one that I have played more than once, and TLJ. Riven too.
I suspect if TLJ 3 comes out, I will play the first two again back to back first.