Here are the top 3 games i've played in the past year
based on my criteria,being a game I could hardly wait to get back to after work.They are AnaCapri,Bioshock,and Rhem3.I played many other good games but these 3 excelled.
What are your 3 top games of the past year and what criteria did you use to choose them?

1. Culpa Innata
2. Sherlock Holmes vs. Arsene Lupin (aka Nemesis)
3. The Lost Crown

1 & 3 for their engrossing, immersive storylines and imaginative puzzles, and 2 for being an absolute joy and such fun to play.

Of the three, Culpa was the game I could barely tear myself away from to sleep/work/eat.

For me:

(1) Last half of darkness <Beyond the spirits EyE>
(2) Lost Crown
(3) Dead reefs

These three had to do with story line..Just had to see how they all ended...

Lost Crown
Latest CSI
Culpa Innata
Agatha Christie, Poirot, Evil Under the Sun
Picked 4 as I am blonde.

Also really loving Diamonds, still playing.
Nearly voted for Lost Crown 3 times as it was so good

The Lost Crown for wonderful story and inivative graphics.
Jack Keane for its wonderful sense of humour.
Darkness Within again a good story and very spooky.
All three had me totally engrossed and I finished each one sad that it had ended. Also all gave me many hours of playing so I felt I had had value for my money.

Games I've played from the last year that I've loved include;
Eastside Story
CSI Hard Evidence
The Darkness Within
The Awakened
Evil Under the Sun
Dead Reefs
The Lost Crown
Diamonds in the Rough
Beyond the Spirit's Eye
Limbo of the Lost
Culpa Innata
& I've probably forgotten a couple! It's so difficult to pick just 3!!!, but if I have to then:

Culpa Innata
Diamonds in the Rough
Beyond the Spirit's Eye

Lost Crown
Sinking Island
Culpa Innata
Dimonds In The Rough
Overclocked
Beyond the Spirits Eye
Darkness Within
These are my faverite ones for this year up to yet

Dragonuk44,
Overclocked made your best list???? I didnt like that one very much.Not enough locations for all the gigantic storage of the game disks.

1. Myst 3 Exile
2. Dreamfall
3. Aura I and II

And many many more, but if I have to choose...

RHEM 3
Ghost in the Sheet
The Lost Crown

Geo Yes I liked overclocked.I got into the story and I was eager .Sinking Island dos nt have a lot of places to go to either .It was the story line I liked and the way they put it togeather and all the clues was there you just had to find them .I guess we cant all like the same the games

Myst: Revelation
Discworld 2
Amber

Andromus,the Myst games make my best ALL TIME list.They just didnt make this list because its been over a year since I played any of them.
------------------------------------------------------
EDIT:JennyP and Jenny100,I think it would have been neat if at the end of Lost Crown the whole game burst into color.All the things that were B&W turned color as if everything was ok with the world again.

And most of them would make my list too. But for this list, Myst 4 was the only Myst game I'd played in the last year.

I thought the game might do that -- especially after the blue sky appeared and the number of colored objects increased partway through the game. I was a little disappointed when the game ended in black and white again.