I enjoyed it.... But, at the same time, I felt somewhat let down. Don't get me wrong, it was a great game, but it did not nearly measure up to the first one. I LOVED that one, and kept it and I'm thinking I may play it again since I'm done with BM 2. This one is not a keeper for me. I think what disappointed me is that I had high hopes of actually being at Black Mirror Castle for the majority of the game, and instead was there at the castle for such a brief period. I really wanted to explore the same areas I looked at before, and it just looked so different now, and most of the places we could visit before were now off limits. (You know, like how in Dark Fall Lost Souls, we pretty much "revisited" the same place as the previous game, and it was the same, yet so very different)
So, if it were a stand alone game, I think I would have enjoyed it a lot more than I did as a sequel to my most favorite and beloved game that I've ever played in the past 11 years and some 155 games.
The story itself was great from start to finish. I, personally had issues with Darren's accent. It was a bit grating to me--kinda reminded me of someone trying to do an imitation of the Kennedys, but maybe that is just me.
Anyway, I'm still hoping there will be a BM 3, but I probably won't be quite as excited as I was for this one to come out.