• 7th Guest (GOG or DotEMU version)
• Aura (DotEMU version)
• Atlantis 2 (aka Beyond Atlantis)
• Book of Unwritten Tales
• Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers (GOG or DotEMU version)
• Lost Horizon
• Moment of Silence
• Morpheus
• Myst 3: Exile
• Obsidian
• Return to Mysterious Island
• RHEM 2
• Riddle of the Sphinx
• Safecracker 2006
• Schizm (aka Schizm: Mysterious Journey)
• (The) Secret of Monkey Island (original version in ScummVM or original version in LucasArts version that's updated to run on newer systems)
• Sentinel: Descendents in Time (aka Realms of Illusion)
• Shivers
• Still Life
• Uru

Some of these (like Morpheus, Obsidian, and Shivers) might have to be played inside Virtual PC on 64-bit Windows 7. But a newbie to gaming isn't necessarily a newbie to running Virtual Machines, so I'm including these games anyway. I'd like to have included Schizm 2, but it had that problem with saving in the elevator level causing a dead end. Though I love all the RHEM games, I'm just including my favorite, RHEM 2, which was the "easiest" for me overall (not that any of them were easy).

Wincey, I wish I was. That would be cool. I could cure all ailments. I would be known as the first person who found a cure for AIDS, and it would be a simple recipe: crocodile tongues, snake's venom, a toenail from an ex-boyfriend or girlfriend and Evian water. A voodoo lady needs a sponsor. The cost of living isn't cheap you know.

Unfortunately, I'm not. I've just looked at the screenshots and the trailers, and I thought it looked like a great game. I'm going to get it off of Gamersgate when it comes out. It's the only place I know of that already has it for pre-order. http://www.gamersgate.com/DD-DECS/the-dark-eye-chains-of-satinav

Is Dreamfall: The Longest Journey considered part of the Hall of Fame? Or just the original Longest Journey?
TIA, Karen

I know, I know. I recommend them with all my hearth GK1, yeah I almost forgot about that game. Truly on of the best and hardest I've played.

Just the original.

Ana

I agree, and I think the same about Obsidian -- another unique and amazing game. But GK1 is probably easier to get now that GOG and DotEMU both have DRM-free versions, updated to run on newer computers, available to download.

About a dozen games with 5 or more votes so far, and all the recent Sherlocks seem to be doing well.
Isabelle is clearly biding its time.

When exactly does a game makes it to the hall of fame? What threshold needs to be achieved?

Also, I understand the hall of fame is a reflection of the games that received the most votes over the years, but for the other games, how difficult would it be, if at all possible, to not only bring us this year's most preferred ones, but also an overall view compilation of all previous years as well?

The basis for the Hall of fame is here
We decided to add Lost Crown this year as even though it doesn't have the longevity of some games, it has been top of the List the last two years and has only ever had Hall of Fame games finish in front of it. We debated waiting another year, but agreed it was a worthy entrant despite its "newness".
Not sure what you mean by a compilation, but as the counter and compiler with Chief my initial reaction is

I just fainted and I don't even do it. Maybe a look at the Annual Games Recommendations in the Archives could sub for a (shudder) compilation.

Gil.

Thanks flotsam and Chief for all your efforts!

Amber: Journeys Beyond
Black Mirror 3
Crime Stories
Darkness Within: In Pursuit of Loath Nolder
Dracula: Last Sanctuary
Dracula: Resurrection
Dreamfall
Gabriel Knight: Sins of the Fathers
Gray Matter
Keepsake
Lost Horizon
Neverhood
Nibiru
Secret Files: Puritas Cordis
Secret Files: Tunguska
Still Life
Tex Murphy: The Pandora Directive

Jeanne

Thank you flotsam & Chief for doing this!

15 Days
Alter Ego
Amber's Blood (Carol Reed)
Art of Murder: Hunt for the Puppeteer
Black Mirror 2
Blackwell Deception (The)
Culpa Innata
Diamonds in the Rough
Gray Matter
LHOD: Society of the Serpent Moon
Lost Horizon
Memento Mori
Overclocked
Runaway 3: A Twist of Fate
Secret Files of Da Vinci: The Forbidden Manuscript
Secret Files 2: Puritas Cordis
Shadow of Memories/Destiny
Sherlock Holmes: Jack the Ripper
To the Moon
Yoomurjak's Ring

It's great to see Yoomurjak's Ring on so many lists. I think it's a classic, maybe one day a hall of fame entrant.

I really enjoyed playing Yoomurjak's Ring. Will there be a sequel? On the Private Moon Studios website it says it's "the first in the line of Jonathan Hunt Adventures."

A sequel would be nice, or 14 Private Moon is one of my favorite active developers.