PETER - that is only 10 and I understand we are allowed to list 15 -
Like everyone else I had trouble narrowing the list down to 15 and not listing all my favorites, the decision as to what I would recommend is very hard but here goes my list, not in any order:
Callahan's Crosstime Saloon
Temujin
Dark Side Of The Moon
Dark Fall
Byzantine The Betrayal
The Dark Eye
The Neverhood
Grim Fandango
ROTS
Beyond Time (The very 1st adventure game I played, very hard)
Nancy Drew Ghost Dogs
Gast The Ghost
Shivers (1)
Schizm
The Sacred Amulet
Thanks Flotsam for doing this large job for us again....
Love, Betty Lou

Thank you really appreciate your hard work putting this together. Here goes!!!! Omega stone
Syberia

The longest journey
Nancy Drew Haunted mansion

Nancy Drew Secret of the scarlet hand
Darkfall
Schizm Black Dahlia Sanitaium The neverhood Amerzone Zork Grand Inquisitor Gabriel Knight 3 Bioscopia Byzantine

Twisty list 2003,
Myst
Riven
Exile
Amber
Shivers
Timelapse
Obsidian
Morpheus
Black Dahlia
Sanitarium
Beyond Atlantis
TLJ
Zork Nemesis
Syberia
Schizm
Wow,that was quick. How about another fifteen?

In no particular order:
The Longest Journey
Syberia
DarkFall
Amber:JB
Gabriel Knight 3
Schizm
Discworld Noir
Blackstone Chronicles
Timelapse
Harvest
Dracula:Last Sanctuary
Seven Games for the Soul
Nancy Drew Haunted Mansion
Nancy Drew Final Scene
Atlantis 2

Susan

Here is my list in No Particular order!

Amber Journeys Beyond
Myst
John Sauls Blackstone Chronicles
Riven
Titanic Adventure out of Time
Beyond Atlantis

OK - well, in no particular order

1-Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis
2-Gabriel Knight 1
3-GK2
4-GK3
5-Broken Sword 1
6-Broken Sword 2
7-The Dig
8-Clue Chronicles: Fatal Illusion
9-Titanic: adventure out of time
10-Monkey Island 1
11-Feeble Files
12-Amerzone
13-Nancy Drew Stay Tuned for Danger

That leaves me with 2 more in case I finish any other games soon (I haven't played all that many <img border="0" alt="" title="" src="graemlins/pacify.gif" /> )

Here's my list (in order )

1. Grim Fandango
2. Myst
3. Gabriel Knight 2: The Beast Within
4. The Last Express
5. Pandora Directive
6. Loom
7. The Secret of Monkey Island
8. Toonstruck
9. Shivers
10. Riven
11. Bad Mojo
12. Day of the Tentacle
13. Morpheus
14. Phantasmagoria 2: A puzzle of flesh
15. Escape from Monkey Island

Okay, here's my list:
1-RealMyst
2-Zork Nemesis
3-The Longest Journey
4-Shivers
5-Gabriel Knight II
6-Amber
7-Dark Eye
8-Dark Fall
9-Syberia
10-Grim Fandango
11-Lighthouse
12-Riven
13-Myst Exile
14-Tex Murphy-Pandora Directive
15-Timelapse

OK here we go:

1. Syberia
2. The Longest Journey
3. Gabriel Knight 1
4. Gabriel Knight 2
5. Stupid Invaders
6. Grim Fandango
7. King's Quest 6
8. Monkey Island 3
9. Zork Grand Inquisitor
10. Amber Journeys Beyond
11. Broken Sword 1
12. Broken Sword 2
13. Legend of Kyrandia - Book 1
14. The Journeyman Project 3 - Legacy of Time
15. Sanitarium

O.K. here goes:
Amber Journeys Beyond
Blackstone Chronicles
Dark Eye
Dark Fall
Discworld Noir
Gabriel Knight: The Beast Within
Inherent Evil: The Haunted Hotel
Law and Order
Morpheus
Nancy Drew: Ghost Dogs of Moon Lake
Post Mortem
Sanitarium
Syberia
The Uninvited
The Watchmaker

Since I have only been playing AGs a short time, I will only list my top 5 of the total of 22 games that I have finished.( out of these 22, three were action games.) Due to some serious BAAGing I now have 24 games waiting to be played. I might add that my choices of games come from lists like this and reviews-have picked up some of the best older games this way. Anyway, here are mine so far:
Tex Murphy-Under a killing Moon
The Longest Journey
Amerzone
Zork Nemisis
Riven

The Day of the Tentacle
Callahan's Crosstime Saloon
Discworld 2
Grim Fandango
Zork Grand Inquistor
Obsidian
The Longest Journey
Chronomaster
Gateway2: Homeworld
Tex Murphy: The Pandora Directive
Mission Critical
Death Gate
Gabriel Knight 1
Dark Fall
Sanitarium

From light, humor and happy atmosphere to dark, dramatic, heavy one...

Hi all,
My first periodic update sees the top 5 being:

The Longest Journey
Syberia
Dark Fall
GK2
Riven

The big movers are clearly the two newbies of last year.
The top 5 have been listed by nearly 50% of all participants.
139 games (allowing for my errors) have already been mentioned, 25 of them more than 10 times.

Finally, we already have more than half last years members participating, so are well on the way to having the most informed list yet.

flotsam

MY CURRENT TOP 15:

1. THE LONGEST JOURNEY
2. MONKEY ISLAND
3. MYST
4. SIMON THE SORCEROR 2
5. BROKEN SWORD
6. SIMON THE SORCEROR
7. SYBERIA
8. MONKEY ISLAND 2
9. DISKWORLD NOIR
10. DAY OF THE TENTACLE
11. RIVEN
12. EXILE
13. BROKEN SWORD 2
14. CURSE OF MONKEY ISLAND
15. WATCHMAKER

OK, biting the bullet.. have been thinking about these for days... no particular order..

Syberia
Dark Fall
Myst 3 - exile
Full Throttle
Day of the Tentacle
Companions of Xanth
Post Mortem
Morpheus
Legend of the Prophet
Secrets of Alamut
Curse of Monkey Island
GK 1
GK 2
Sanitarium
Discworld 1

I bet I'll want to change my mind too!!!!

Hugs

Tig