Nancy Drew 19: The Haunting of Castle Malloy



Genre:   Adventure

Developer & Publisher:    Her Interactive

Released:  September 2008 

PC Requirements:   1 GHz or greater Pentium or equivalent class CPU, 128 MB of RAM, 1 GB or more of hard drive space, 32 MB DirectX 9.0 compatible video card, 16 bit DirectX compatible sound card, 24X CD-ROM drive, mouse, and speakers


Additional Screenshots




by flotsam


You have to admire a franchise that is still going strong at nineteen games, with two more already in production. However given that there are at least 300 titles if you count the original publications plus the Simon & Schuster Nancy Drew Mysteries and Nancy Drew Files, there is plenty of fodder to keep Her Interactive going for quite some time.

This is about the sixth Nancy Drew game I have played, although a number of those were with one or other of my daughters. My daughters are now far more interested in real life than they are in gaming, so I now fly solo. I have to confess Nancy Drew is not my first choice when it comes to choosing a new game to play, and that to date I have played them in order to review them. But I also have to confess that I was pleasantly surprised with The Haunting of Castle Malloy, and found it a definite step up from The Creature of Kapu Cave, the last Nancy Drew game I had played.

This time Nancy is in Ireland, to be maid of honour at Kyler Mallory’s wedding. Except that Matt the groom is missing, perhaps playing one of his infamous pranks, or perhaps taken by fairies or something more sinister. Kit probably knows more than he is admitting, and Donal knows all there is to know about folklore. If a banshee is involved, then death is close at hand; Matt’s maybe?

Nancy of course is the one to set things right. Sleuthing is what she does, and is what she does here. Along with sorting out some wedding details as she goes – seating charts and wedding invitations are just two of her contributions.

3 bags full

Indeed, there is no end to Nancy’s talents. By the time she leaves to fly back to the United States, she will have mixed drinks at the local tavern, filled in on drums for a missing musician, mustered and shorn a pen full of sheep and completed upwards of twenty puzzles of varying complexity. Downtime is not in Nancy’s vocabulary.

To me, the puzzles were the high point. Which is not something I expected. I described many of the puzzles in Kapu Cave as “repetitious filler”, and whilst there is some of that here, it’s the exception rather than the rule. They are still a little “stuck on” rather than being integrated into the plot, but that’s a minor complaint. Littered right through the game, they provide a good degree of interest and challenge.

With so many of them, you are bound to find ones you like and ones you don’t. Collecting sheep was a bit of a dud, and mixing drinks and playing the drums were a little too arcade like for my tastes. So too were playing the games machines in the tavern. But if they are to your liking you can play them more than once for fun, and perhaps get a tick in the achievements certificate at the end of the game. Some will be familiar – a slider, a Tower of Hanoi and placing gear wheels on a machine for example – but others are less so. I particularly enjoyed the dollhouse puzzles, in which the placement of the dolls was akin to a logic puzzle, and the otter puzzle gave me a challenge in excess of its seeming simplicity.

These puzzles are fairly well self-contained, everything you need being right there in front of you, albeit perhaps after you have found a piece or two. Other puzzles are more complex, requiring note taking and book reading and a bit of brain power to unravel their objectives and then their solutions. The standing stones and the tower desk puzzles are good examples. Other puzzles also intersect, with the solution in one feeding into the solution of the next – the answer to lowering the castle wall requires an understanding of a successful solve elsewhere.

You will come across many of the puzzles right from the start, although you may not have all the pieces necessary. Both the slider and the gear wheel puzzles, for instance, can be accessed as soon as you arrive at the Castle. However, you will need to solve other puzzles to be rewarded with the pieces necessary to complete them. This is common throughout the game, with almost every puzzle solve giving you something necessary elsewhere. You find some objects lying around, but most you have to earn.

The plot by comparison was a little drab, although I wasn’t expecting the high-tech (if a little silly) finale amongst the bogs and fens and leprechauns. The voice acting is good as always, and all dialogue comes with subtitles. Mild dialogue trees give you some involvement in the provision of information, although I couldn’t find a way to skip or advance the dialogue. A minor irritation if you have heard something before or have read ahead. 

On your own

In the last few games the Hardy Boys have been participants, but they are absent here, preferring instead to be solving their own Hidden Theft. You can ring Ned and Bess, but seemingly for a chat and little else. As with all Nancy Drew games, you can play as a Junior or Senior detective, and whilst Ned and/or Bess gave you clues as a Junior detective in earlier games I played, at Castle Malloy you get them (so it seems) from a fortunetelling machine. Junior detective also gives you a task list to keep track of what to do, something Nancy says you do not need as a Senior detective, and a few of the puzzles at least have less complicated solves as a Junior detective.

Whichever you choose, a tutorial is available at the start of the game to get you familiar with the interface and game mechanics. You can ignore it if you wish. Instructions abound for many of the conundrums throughout the game, but some puzzles require a bit of hit and miss to work out how they work. I thought at times this was a little unbalanced – the instructions for mixing drinks, for instance, are voluminous, yet nonexistent for disposing of the chemicals. I exploded (literally) quite a few times just working out how to manipulate the machinery involved.

Whether playing as a Junior or Senior, exploding, drowning in the bog, or plummeting down a missing stairwell results in a second (or third or fourth) chance that returns you to just prior to the fatal moment. So there is no need to worry about saving as you go in case of disaster. Saving, though, can help you save money in undertaking tasks that require a coin or two; simply restore if you don’t like the result!

An aspect I hadn’t come across in earlier games was a third person perspective when Nancy travels outside the castle between locations. Simply drag the magnifying glass cursor and off she goes.

How to

A simple set of active cursors will tell you there are things to be examined or interacted with. Icons along the bottom of the screen give you access to your inventory, Nancy’s journal and (if playing Junior detective) the task list. The save and load screens are also accessible there. A purse shows your current money situation, and some puzzles will result in a temporary icon needed as part of the solution. Point and click your way around in response to icons which show where you can move and turn.

What else? There is a maze which you only have to traverse once, and you can tweak various settings. The musical score was okay, and I liked that when I pressed the exit icon, the game did exactly that (no asking was I sure or anything else). You get a little typed out “good news, bad news” message when you meet an untimely end. Once or twice this is amusing, but after a while becomes irritating when all you want to do is try again. The sheep hair designs are pretty freaky.

For some reason, the game would not start by using the desktop icon or the program icon in the start menu, even after I removed and reloaded the game. I had to start through the autorun icon on one of the discs. Not a big deal, but not something that should occur.

Oh, and Nancy runs off the road whilst talking on a mobile phone at the start of the game. A lesson to her and everyone else.

The Haunting of Castle Malloy was certainly the best experience I have had with Nancy Drew. If you haven’t played one before, my advice is start with this. If you have played before and have become a little jaded with the offerings, you (like me) might be pleasantly surprised. And for all those fans who have played all previous eighteen and can’t wait to get to the Bahamas in the next instalment, you probably didn’t need any of this.


October 2008

design copyright © 2008 GameBoomers Group

 GB Reviews Index