Yes, petty darned scary -- but I think Call of Cthulhu was even worse. That one was creeeeepy. The hotel escape....brrrrrr.
These days it's difficult for me to get freaked by a game because since our last move I no longer have my own office in a dank, dark basement. Now I have a desk in a sunny room looking out over the ocean.
Of course, that's where Cthulhu lives...isn't it?