I apologize that I am one who does not participate. I just am far behind in playing these games and I like MOST of them that I play so find it hard to weed any one out for recommendation.
I have, however, purchased some games that I've seen recommended in that thread as well as in the other threads, most recently Macabre Mysteries: Curse of the Nightingale. I even downloaded it right away but have not yet started to play it. I bought it a few days ago with a code emailed to me by Big Fish for $4.99.
So, I am sorry it is just the same few people contributing but please know that IT IS appreciated by us others.