Chuck, I haven't played this for a while, so I can't remember exactly what the amulet looks like, but you can do a search for a specific item or quest within most walkthroughs. I'm pretty sure that the amulet is around Dyan. It was sitting on a ledge or a bench. Have you searched the whole of the pagan area? The amulet is quite small, I think.
No fancy-pantsy Elven dagger-twirlers. Just tough guys.