It's a tradition in our family, to buy an anonymous exchange gift that starts with a certain letter of the alphabet. This year the letter is "I". The gift can't cost any more than $10-$15. Any ideas?

some nice Ice cube trays

Imprint of someone's hands and/or feet (children or grand-children) and frame it

Incense
ITunes gift card

Idiot-proof mobile phone - Hi Cue

Bernie

An Ivy plant or an Indian Headdress (or other Indian clothing), perhaps accompanied by a written incivility!

Hi maryerbee I like that idea. We could fill the trays with small bite-size fudge pieces.

I don't know if there IS an idiot-proof mobile phone. If there is it's out of our price range.

I like the I-Tunes card and the ivy. We have imprints of the grandkids in the pool room.

Great suggestions :)

How surprising that you have a "pool room"

Another suggestion...a small Igloo cooler

Don't you guys play Scattergories? How about Italian Ice? Or Identical Icelandic Igloos? Or Imaginary Identical Idols?" (easy to wrap)

how about an "Infusion Water Bottle" ... you can put fruit in the center to flavor the water.

Ice cream maker
iPod
iTunes gift card
iguana
ice skates

Inkwells and INXS albums also spring to mind, and depending upon the age of the recipient perhaps an International Rescue (Thunderbirds) model, and of course an iron (whether for domestic or golfing use) - itching powder might be less welcome.

Great ideas!

I've never played Scattergories. I'll have to check it out.

I thought about instant lottery tickets last night. Those actually do wrap easily