I played this one earlier this month, although I haven't been a paying member at BF for many years now because my buying habits are erratic (we often are traveling for months at a time). Maybe they aren't as strict about their "Today's Game for Members" criterion as it would seem?
Anyway, I thought it was excellent, long-playing (several days), felt like a huge file. Very creative, with many locations. I had a few "WTH?" moments, but nothing to put me off. Puzzles are medium to difficult, just the way I like them. It has the usual pop-ups if you want to hunt Collectibles, but otherwise they are not in your face. Note-taking will be vital unless you have an
excellent memory, because there is a lot of Adventuring-Around to be done. I appreciated that, too. I am bored silly with Casuals that include everything you need in the SAME scene. Duh!
I liked how this game tweaked my Thinkmeat, and I gave it my highest of three ratings. It is marked down as a
Replay on my spreadsheet.
I went for the CE and felt the extra play was worth it.