| 
| 
 
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118254 11/07/03 07:57 PM
11/07/03 07:57 PM
 |  
| Joined:  Oct 2003 Posts: 12,097
 The Garden State
LadyKestrel
   Adept Boomer
 |  
|   Adept Boomer
 
 Joined:  Oct 2003
 Posts: 12,097
 The Garden State
 | 
CNW400, Believe it or not, there is a Standard American English which speech-language pathologists are taught in college in the US.  The International Phonetic Alphabet was established in the late 1880s.  It was first concerned with phonetics as applied to teaching English, but as more countries became involved, the alphabet became truly international and has survived to this day with very few changes.  As you know, the same letters can have entirely different sounds.  For instance, the "c" in city  makes the "s" sound and the "c" in cage  makes the "k" sound.  The IPA has a symbol for each sound in our language.  Although we use only 26 letters in English, there are (dredging up very old memory) 44 symbols that represent the different sounds or phonemes in Am. English.  The different dialects we hear are simply variations on a theme that have been established regionally.  They occur because of changes in voice quality, vowel distortions or prolongations, omissions or additions of sounds, inflections, and the influences of other languages, among other things.  The phonetic alphabet has modifying symbols to show these variations.   Oh, for pity's sake, I sound like one of my professors.  Sorry!  Class dismissed!     Jeremy Brett was also my favorite Sherlock Holmes.  Holmes' speech should be that of an educated Victorian Londoner.  Anything else would be jarring. Lady K. 
 Fear not the dark itself, but what may lurk within it.
 |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118255 11/08/03 06:09 AM
11/08/03 06:09 AM
 |  
| Joined:  Aug 2000 Posts: 1,657
 Haifa; ISRAEL
LenG
   Addicted Boomer
 |  
|   Addicted Boomer
 
 Joined:  Aug 2000
 Posts: 1,657
 Haifa; ISRAEL
 | 
hër  hërHolmes' speech should be that of an educated Victorian Londoner. Anything else would be jarring. ... as they broadcast from the House of Commons. (Apologies to LadyKestrel if my phonemes are a bit phony!    |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118258 11/08/03 09:34 AM
11/08/03 09:34 AM
 |  
| Joined:  Apr 2001 Posts: 15,679
 England
tigger
   Graduate Boomer
 |  
|   Graduate Boomer
 
 Joined:  Apr 2001
 Posts: 15,679
 England
 | 
a Llewellyn then??  The double ll is a Welsh spelling.. St.John as I recall is the only one which gives the 'sinjun' sound.. Tig    
 A bounce a day keeps the doctor away!!
 Playing  Sims2,  Sherlock, Phantom of Venice
 Reading  Storm Breaking
 |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118260 11/08/03 10:03 AM
11/08/03 10:03 AM
 |  
| Joined:  Apr 2001 Posts: 15,679
 England
tigger
   Graduate Boomer
 |  
|   Graduate Boomer
 
 Joined:  Apr 2001
 Posts: 15,679
 England
 | 
OK, a real verbal conundrum.. say Slaithwaite properly!! Tig    
 A bounce a day keeps the doctor away!!
 Playing  Sims2,  Sherlock, Phantom of Venice
 Reading  Storm Breaking
 |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118261 11/08/03 10:25 AM
11/08/03 10:25 AM
 |  
| Joined:  Aug 2000 Posts: 1,657
 Haifa; ISRAEL
LenG
   Addicted Boomer
 |  
|   Addicted Boomer
 
 Joined:  Aug 2000
 Posts: 1,657
 Haifa; ISRAEL
 | 
CHUM-LEE (CHUM as in "Dumb" ... or a more obvious one --- but may be considered a bit   rude      ). And what about one of my favorite sauces ... WORCESTER ! |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118262 11/08/03 10:32 AM
11/08/03 10:32 AM
 |  
| Joined:  Apr 2003 Posts: 1,254
 England
TheDerman
   Addicted Boomer
 |  
|   Addicted Boomer
 
 Joined:  Apr 2003
 Posts: 1,254
 England
 | 
St.John (Sinjun) - wasn't that Roger Moore's fake name in A View To A Kill? 
 Derman
 |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118265 11/08/03 11:46 PM
11/08/03 11:46 PM
 |  
| Joined:  Apr 2001 Posts: 15,679
 England
tigger
   Graduate Boomer
 |  
|   Graduate Boomer
 
 Joined:  Apr 2001
 Posts: 15,679
 England
 | 
not a bad try Becky!! Its actually pronounced Slawit    
 A bounce a day keeps the doctor away!!
 Playing  Sims2,  Sherlock, Phantom of Venice
 Reading  Storm Breaking
 |  |  |  
| 
| 
|  Re: Say your word! Should Sherlock Holmes speak in British or American English?
 #118266 11/09/03 01:12 AM
11/09/03 01:12 AM
 |  
| Anonymous
 Unregistered
 |  
| Anonymous Unregistered
 
 
 
 
 | 
   What is a Sletweh?  As an Aussie, I would pronounce it slet-wear! Isn't the English language amazing? |  |  |  
 
 |  |